Birkenstock Mayari Vs Arizona: Which Is Right For You? [2024 Guide]

Price Ratke 11 May 2025

Are you torn between the classic comfort of the Arizona Birkenstocks and the stylish allure of the Mayari? Choosing between the Birkenstock Arizona and Mayari models is a decision that hinges on personal preference, fit, and aesthetic sensibilities. Both offer the renowned Birkenstock comfort and durability, but cater to slightly different needs and styles.

Many who've owned the Arizona rave about the minimal break-in period and the sheer comfort of the classic two-strap design. Switching to the Mayari, however, can bring about questions regarding comparative comfort. The Birkenstock Mayari offers the same durability and utility synonymous with the brand, but presents a unique twist on the traditional sandal silhouette. The Mayari design incorporates a toe loop, a feature that can significantly impact the overall feel and fit. While some find this toe loop adds security and a distinct style, others struggle with the fit, particularly if it's not adjustable, unlike the toe loops found on Chacos. Ultimately, the best approach is to try on both styles to determine which fits your foot best. Personal preference reigns supreme; some find the Mayari more aesthetically pleasing, feeling the Arizona appears too bulky on their feet, while others find the Arizona provides the classic Birkenstock feel they know and love.

Feature	Birkenstock Arizona	Birkenstock Mayari
Design	Classic two-strap sandal	Two slim straps with a toe loop
Material	Natural and renewable materials; various leathers (synthetic, patent, suede)	Vegan options available; anatomical cork footbed
Style	Sportier, classic, basic	Dainty, elegant, modern
Fit	Generally wider	More narrow
Adjustability	Adjustable straps	Adjustable straps, but toe loop is not adjustable
Colors	Variety of colors, including light and summery tones	Variety of colors
Sizes	Available in various sizes, some up to size 46	Available in various sizes
Comfort	Easy to slip on, classic Birkenstock comfort	Toe loop may require some getting used to
Versatility	Goes well with any look; great for slipping on	Suitable for beach, trails, or city wear
Similar Styles	Florida	Gizeh

Reference website: Birkenstock Official Website

The Birkenstock Mayari boasts a design featuring two slim straps and that distinguishing toe loop. Many consider it a hybrid of the Arizona and the Gizeh, offering a sleek and modern feel thanks to its thinner straps. The Birkenstock Arizona, on the other hand, is primarily crafted from natural and renewable materials, with straps available in diverse leathers, including synthetic, patent, and suede options. The Arizona model also comes in light and summery tones like white and silver, with some variations available up to size 46.

So, what kind of clothing complements the Mayari? In contrast to the Arizona's sportier and more classic appeal, the Mayari exudes a dainty, elegant charm, making it a versatile choice for various outfits. For those seeking vegan options, the vegan Mayari Birkenstocks offer a crossover sandal with a toe strap. Like all Birkenstock models, the Mayari vegan variant features the signature anatomical cork footbed, with the upper crafted from Birkenstocks proprietary vegan leathers. Testers often receive compliments when wearing this sandal, and the Birkenstock Arizona also scores high in the style category.

The Mayari sandals by Birkenstock are ideal for summertime, whether you're at the beach, on trails, or navigating the city. The EVA outsoles provide protection and cushioning, while the arch and heel support ensure proper foot alignment. Some wearers have reported engaging in various activities, such as walking, climbing, and playing volleyball, while wearing their Mayari sandals, attesting to their secure fit. In some cases, the Mayari sandals stay on so well that they almost need to be kicked off, contrasting with models like the Florida (similar to the Arizona), which can come off more easily. The reasons for this difference in security might stem from the style or the choice between a regular or soft footbed.

For those new to Birkenstocks and deciding between the Mayari and Gizeh for summer sandals, the choice depends on personal preference and foot shape. Regarding sizing, sticking with a 38 is often recommended. Many have expressed love for the Birkenstock Unisex Arizona Blue Birko Flor sandals, praising the soft and comfortable suede material for its breathability and durability. The foam layer in the footbed provides exceptional cushioning.

The Arizona excels as a slip-on sandal, offering classic Birkenstock comfort and a trendy, iconic look. While the Arizona holds a certain timeless appeal, the Mayari's aesthetics are equally appreciated, making the decision a matter of personal taste. When considering Birkenstocks for a younger sibling, the dilemma of choosing between styles or opting for both arises. The classic, basic Birkenstock shoe, like the Arizona, has captured hearts worldwide and pairs well with any ensemble. Its also worth noting the numerous styles available within the Birkenstock Arizona line.

For those with paler skin tones, opting for iron over black in the Arizona, or choosing black in the Gizeh or Mayari over the Arizona, can provide a less stark contrast. Colors like mink over sand suede, velvet grey suede over black suede, tobacco over habana oiled leather, oiled blue, and zinfandel can complement paler skin tones beautifully. The Arizona suedes are often lauded for their exceptional comfort. Some find the Gizeh uncomfortable due to the angle of the thong, while the Mayari emerges as a second favorite for many. The Mayaris comfort and lack of irritation on the top of the foot are often highlighted. For many, Birkenstocks are among the most comfortable shoes they own. While the strap around the Mayari toe may require some initial adjustment, it doesn't feel like a typical thong sandal. The Mayaris narrower fit, compared to the Arizona, makes it an ideal choice for those with narrower feet.

Ultimately, the choice between the Mayari and Arizona Birkenstocks comes down to individual preferences, foot shape, and lifestyle. Trying both styles on and considering the pros and cons of each will ensure you select the perfect pair for your needs.